Nolan Thebiay   33 | Pitcher

Thebiay (thee-bee) is back for his second season with Evansville in 2026. He had a 2.88 ERA in 43.2 IP last season, having the second-most IP out of the Otters' bullpen. After his freshman season at Chemeketa Community College in 2021, he played two seasons with Montana State-Billings, combining for only 7.1 IP combined in those years. He played his last two collegiate seasons at Division II Jessup, where he was an All-PacWest Third Team selection in his senior year.